Tag Archives: dispensary

Alternatives to Bankruptcy for Cannabis Companies: Part 1

By Brent Salmons, Yuefan Wang
No Comments

The problems facing the cannabis industry arising from its ongoing status as a federally illegal enterprise are numerous and well documented: 280E tax burdens, limited access to banking, exclusion from capital markets, uneven access to federal intellectual property right protections and the inability to access the stream of interstate commerce. The recent woes faced by cannabis companies operating in mature markets reveal another key legal hurdle for cannabis companies, their investors and their creditors: the inability to access federal bankruptcy protection. However, cannabis companies may have access to a number of contractual and state law remedies to deal with insolvency and other financial woes.

Background

Bankruptcy laws in the United States are unique in the world; nowhere else is access to bankruptcy so available or forgiving for ordinary citizens and companies alike, allowing debtors a fresh start by either liquidating their assets or reorganizing their debt. Commentators have observed that such favorable bankruptcy laws encourage entrepreneurship and have been at least partially responsible for American innovation. Indeed, the ability of Congress to enact bankruptcy laws is enshrined in the United States Constitution. Like almost all laws in the U.S. at the time, bankruptcy was originally the domain of the various states; it was not until the late 18th century that Congress saw the importance of a uniform set of protections for debtors and passed the first federal bankruptcy law in 1800; since then, bankruptcy has been exclusively the purview of federal law, with current bankruptcy law governed by the United States Bankruptcy Code.

Yuefan Wang, attorney at Husch Blackwell

This exclusivity, however, poses a problem for state-regulated cannabis businesses: because cannabis is federally illegal, in the eyes of the United States Trustee Program, a division of the United States Department of Justice responsible for overseeing the administration of bankruptcy proceedings, the reorganization of any cannabis business amounts to “supervis[ing] an ongoing criminal enterprise regardless of its status under state law.” Therefore, since there is no such thing as state law bankruptcy, even cannabis companies operating in full compliance with state laws do not have access to any bankruptcy protections.1

All financing transactions, whether debt or equity, occur in the shadow of bankruptcy. The basic distinction between debt and equity is predicated on the favorable treatment of holders of the former compared to holders of the latter (within debt, the favorable treatment of secured debt over unsecured debt), and this is true, especially in bankruptcy. Even beyond distribution priorities, the Bankruptcy Code’s provisions on automatic stays, avoiding powers, and discharge fundamentally shape the relationship between debtors and creditors: a bankruptcy judge has the power to impose the Bankruptcy Code on the relationship between a debtor and its creditors, no matter their previous contractual relationships. Just as the possibility of litigation is a Sword of Damocles hanging over any legal disputes, the prospect of a bankruptcy filing affects any negotiations between a debtor and its creditors ab initio. Therefore, when financial problems arise and a cannabis company must begin the difficult task of approaching its lenders for relief, it does so without an effective incentive for creditors to come to the table available to other companies in otherwise similar situations.

Alternatives to Bankruptcy

Just as disputants often prefer the contractual certainty of a settlement agreement to the capriciousness of a jury, debtors and creditors may choose extra-judicial solutions for insolvency. The downward trend in bankruptcies over the last few decades may partially be the product of such out-of-court arrangements, and debtors and creditors are increasingly comfortable with them as an alternative to voluntary or involuntary bankruptcy filing. While the effectiveness of these solutions is, in industries other than cannabis, ultimately evaluated with bankruptcy in mind, these solutions may also be preferable for a creditor of a cannabis company that is defaulting on its obligations.

Contractual Remedies: Lender Workouts, Exchange Offers and Composition Agreements

Given that the relationship between a debtor and its creditors is essentially contractual, the parties may choose to modify their relationship in any manner to which they can mutually agree. A lender workout is an agreement for a financially distressed company to adjust its debt obligations with a creditor (or often multiple creditors given that a lender’s payment obligations to one creditor necessarily affect its obligations to its other creditors). These contractual adjustments are tailored to the particular situation and can take the form of deferrals of payments of interest or principal, extensions of maturity dates, covenant relief (e.g., adjustment of the lender’s debt-to-asset ratio or other financial covenants which would otherwise trigger an event of default), and/or debt-for-equity swaps. This last option (including its related concepts, such as grants of options or warrants) is especially prevalent in the cannabis industry, given that cannabis companies often do not have traditional bank debt (though, at the same time, such solutions may be increasingly unattractive to creditors given lower valuations and the prevalence of equity as a form of consideration in cannabis mergers and acquisitions transactions).

Brent Salmons, attorney at Husch Blackwell

Similarly, an exchange offer restructures a faltering company’s capital stack. Typically, a company facing a default will offer its equity-holders new debt or equity securities in exchange for its outstanding debt securities, which new securities have more favorable terms, such as covenants, events of defaults and maturity. Exchange offers have the same goal as lender workouts in that they seek to eliminate a class of securities with an impending maturity date, event of default or breach of a covenant.

Composition agreements are contractual arrangements between a debtor and its creditors whereby the creditors agree to accept less favorable claims in order for the debtor to reorganize its operations so that the debtor’s future inflows can meet its reduced outflows, with the alternative being a complete collapse of the debtor (in which case no one, or perhaps only the most senior secure lenders, is repaid). These agreements often provide for oversight by a committee of the creditors and will often involve contractual promises by creditors to forbear from exercising their previously existing rights until a defined triggering event.

Statutory Remedies: UCC Article 9 Sales and ABCs

If the contractual remedies described above are akin to Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings, whereby a company in dire (but ultimately salvageable) straits continues to operate while its debt obligations are reorganized, state law statutory remedies are analogous to Chapter 7 bankruptcy proceedings; the business is a sinking ship and must liquidate its assets to maximize payments to its creditors (in the bankruptcy context, per the rules of absolute priority). Such liquidation is governed by rules under state law which may be available to cannabis companies.

If a creditor has a security interest in the collateral of a debtor, then the most popular option is usually a sale under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). The UCC is a standardized set of laws and regulations for conducting business, including lending. The UCC itself is not law; rather it is a codex that has been adopted by most states and incorporated into their statutes as law, usually with some variations. UCC Article 9 deals with secured transactions and, in particular, provides for the sale and disposition of collateral subject to a security interest upon a default by the debtor. Similar to a §363 sale under the Bankruptcy Code, a sale under UCC Article 9 provides for a “friendly foreclosure” whereby a defaulting debtor and its lenders cooperate to facilitate a sale of the secured collateral.

Article 9 imposes certain parameters on such dispositions, including that foreclosure sales be “commercially reasonable”, which the UCC specifies as meaning that the collateral be sold in a reasonable and customary manner on a recognized market, at then-current market prices. If the sale was approved in a judicial proceeding, by a bona fide creditors’ committee, by a representative of creditors or by an assignee for the benefit of creditors, then this creates a presumption of commercial reasonability under the UCC.

A less common option is an assignment for the benefit of creditors (ABCs). Laws governing such assignments vary by state and are generally rare, with California being a notable exception where both ABCs are more common and where cannabis is legal. An ABC is initiated by the debtor, which then enters into an agreement to assign its assets to a third-party assignee, which holds such assets in trust for the benefit of the creditors and is then responsible for their liquidation, similar in principle to a trustee in bankruptcy.

ABCs, however, are generally not suitable for cannabis companies as the third-party assignee would not be able to take possession of a licensed cannabis business, or certain assets such as cannabis plants, distillates and other products, without itself being licensed by the relevant state regulatory agency. A similar problem occurs under Article 9 sales, whereby the purchaser of the collateral must be licensed in order to possess and operate cannabis product and, more importantly, the all-important state-issued licenses which provide a cannabis company with the authority to operate as such; the pool of potential purchasers is therefore limited to those purchasers already licensed or which are willing to undergo the burdensome process of becoming licensed, hence shrinking the market for such assets and reducing their value. These issues may be resolved in some states by the assignor/seller entering into a management services agreement with the assignee/purchaser, pursuant to which the assignee/purchaser effectively manages the operations of the cannabis business. These agreements, however, need to be carefully drafted so that they are not seen as constituting ownership of the business by the assignee/purchaser (until the actual transfer of the licenses occurs), as defined under applicable state law.


  1. While absolutely true for “plant-touching” companies, recent cases in the federal Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals provide some (fact-dependent) hope for cannabis-adjacent companies such as those housing the employees or intellectual property of a plant-touching operational cannabis company (this structure itself largely a solution to deal with federal illegality).

Safety & Compliance in the Absence of Regulatory Clarity & Consistency

By Joel Chappelle
No Comments

As the legal landscape surrounding cannabis continues to evolve, the creation of robust, sensible and consistent safety regulations remains stalled. A patchwork of broadly inconsistent state rules and regulations, along with years of federal inaction and policy stagnation have the potential to create significant risks for consumers. Given the industry’s explosive, multi-billion-dollar growth, consumers have access to an ever-increasing number of products produced by an increasing number of actors, pursuant to widely divergent standards and rules. Given this, the industry would be well-served to take on the responsibility of promulgating a coherent regulatory framework with robust (but sensible) safety regulations. The importance of collaboration among cannabis industry stakeholders cannot be overstated if we are to develop and adopt consistent standards that guarantee product safety at every step of the supply chain.

Joel Chappelle, along with several renowned experts, will lead the Seed to Sale Safety Workshop at the Cannabis Quality Conference this October 16 in New Jersey. Click here to learn more. Inconsistencies in safety standards and regulations open the door to a range of potential hazards, including contaminant risk, labeling accuracy, potency quantification and many others. Absent a clear understanding of seed-to-sale risks, many of which are not even mentioned in state regulations, cannabis companies face significant exposure, often without even knowing it.

To mitigate these risks, it is vitally important for the cannabis industry to collaborate in the ongoing development of safety standards. This means understanding and implementing safety measures starting with the cultivation process. Careful consideration should be given to factors such as the use of pesticides and herbicides, soil quality and irrigation methods. Standardized safety testing to ensure uniformity between products for potency, contaminants, heavy metals and microbial organisms is crucial to consumer safety. Accurate and comprehensive labeling is likewise necessary for consumers to be adequately informed.

For as long as consistent state and federal guidelines governing cannabis safety remain elusive, the need for industry self-regulation will be paramount. Cannabis companies must work together to share best practices, establish standard operating procedures and adopt stringent safety measures. By promoting transparency and collaboration, stakeholders can build credibility and consumer trust while fostering a safer and more reputable industry.

As the industry continues to grow, it is incumbent upon all stakeholders to continue prioritizing consumer safety through, among other things, a focus on education and inter-industry collaboration, if we are to continue cultivating a trustworthy and sustainable cannabis market for the future. The path forward will require stakeholders to pursue continuous education, improvement, and collaboration in the development of a holistic safety framework capable of ensuring consumer safety.

german flag

Unpacking the New German Cannabis Reform Bill

By Michael Sassano
No Comments
german flag

Following the German cannabis reform movement is like watching a snowboard jump competition. We launch into the big jump with lofty promises, only to face the difficulty of gaining meaningful, immediate momentum at the bottom of the halfpipe. Nevertheless, we persevere through smaller political moves that set us up for more advanced regulatory jumps, all the while believing that broader cannabis legalization requires sacrifice and the skills to navigate the course properly.

The Cannabis Act is a significant step forward. Although we rarely get exactly what we want, it holds promise for the EU-GMP cannabis producers that have invested heavily in creating a global, pharmaceutical-grade market.

Reforms to Medical Cannabis in Germany

The Cannabis Act proposes reforms to how doctors prescribe cannabis, removing the narcotic designation that stigmatized prescriptions and created liabilities for doctors. If passed, doctors and telemedicine groups will be able to prescribe cannabis for almost any condition without fear of lengthy paperwork or the stigma of controlled substance liabilities.

This framework is reminiscent of early medical programs in the USA and Canada. In these countries, obtaining a prescription for cannabis became steadily easier as patient-driven demand took over. As we can see, the cannabis industries in these nations have flourished.

Home Cannabis Cultivation for German Citizens: A Small Step Forward

german flag
Photo: Ian McWilliams, Flickr

Allowing citizens to grow three cannabis plants at home is not monumental. However, it is a strong symbolic statement about how accessible the cannabis plant should be to the broader population and is the first step toward a decriminalization bill.

This Act signals growing national acceptance from politicians and a shift toward treating the plant as a right for all Germans. Though small, this change needs applause from both institutional cannabis producers and the cannabis advocates that have fought so hard to bring it to fruition.

Cannabis Social Clubs in Germany

Social clubs are a completely unproven economic model, reminiscent of “coffee shop” models paired with small legal grows to service the club. These social clubs are a legal version of those around Barcelona and mirror proposals in Malta and Switzerland.

Though novel, the social club model is a positive shift toward a smaller-scale adoption of cannabis. It addresses a niche market for flower connoisseurs and appeals to cannabis entrepreneurs who want to explore their green thumb. The effect on the illicit market is yet to be seen, just like home grows, but progress here sets us up for the next move.

Looking Toward German Dispensaries

Cannabis institutional investors and producers are all looking towards the next step: American- and Canadian-style dispensaries that allow any adult to walk into a store and purchase a high-quality, regulated product. These establishments will likely compete directly with the illicit market and produce the capital necessary to push cannabis toward national legalization. Although not in the current text of the bill, all eyes are on the future as we celebrate our progress thus far.

The Cannabis Act Holds Promise for the Future

There is something for everyone in the latest Cannabis Act, whether you are a home enthusiast, advocate, members-only green thumb enthusiast or large-scale institutional player. This bill leaves little doubt that we are moving through the legalization course. There is much more work to come, but we are moving forward together and have hope for the future of regulated cannabis in Germany.

2023 Cannabis Supply Chain Virtual Conference

By Cannabis Industry Journal Staff
No Comments

2023 Cannabis Supply Chain Virtual Conference

Click here to watch the recording

Agenda

Cannabis Packaging Solutions: Navigating Regulations, Quality & Environmental Impact
Jack Grover, Founder & CEO, Grove Bags

In the cannabis industry, packaging regulations and quality standards play a pivotal role in ensuring consumer safety, product integrity, and environmental sustainability. Join Jack Grover, CEO of Grove Bags, as he delves into the multifaceted landscape of cannabis packaging. The presentation will explore the diverse aspects of packaging regulations, highlighting childproofing requirements and the varying standards across different states. With a focus on transparency, Jack will discuss the merits of a variety of packaging options and their impact on product quality, shelf life, and health. Additionally, he will provide valuable insights into maintaining regulatory compliance, and how all of the above impacts a cultivator’s and end-user’s experience throughout the supply chain. Through this thought-provoking presentation, attendees will gain a comprehensive understanding of the intricate relationship between packaging, regulations, product quality, and environmental impact throughout the global cannabis supply chain.

TechTalk Sponsored by BIPOCann
Ernest Toney, Founder, BIPOCann

Automation Unleashed: Revolutionizing the Cannabis Industry Value Chain
Nohtal Partansky, CEO, Sorting Robotics

Join Nohtal Partansky, CEO of Sorting Robotics, as he explores the transformative potential of automation throughout the cannabis industry value chain. In this thought-provoking session, Nohtal will delve into various use cases of automation, highlighting its significant impact on efficiency, productivity, quality, and safety. This presentation makes a compelling argument for embracing automation as a strategic advantage. Nohtal will unveil the financial benefits, demonstrating how automation reduces overhead costs and drives higher profitability for businesses. He will also address the remote argument, emphasizing how automation minimizes the risk of human error and enhances operational safety. Nohtal will go on to debunk common misconceptions surrounding automation, assuring attendees that it can augment human capabilities rather than replace jobs. The performance argument will shine a light on how automation guarantees consistent product quality, providing consumers with reliable experiences every time. In addition, Nohtal will delve into the contamination argument, showcasing how automation significantly reduces the risk of human error and contamination, thereby improving product safety. Attendees will gain insights into how automation eliminates tedious and overhead-heavy tasks, freeing up resources for more strategic initiatives.

Optimizing Your Cash Handling through Automation, Analytics & Reporting
Shawn Kruger, SVP, Product & Strategy, Avivatech

Shawn Kruger will share how developing a cash automation strategy saves time and costs, ensuring the security and visibility of cash inventory in/across dispensaries, delivery operations and/or cultivation centers. As an industry with limited access to traditional banking accounts, a cash automation strategy supports the business’ goals in ensuring all cash is secure and accounted for, provides the insights needed for all back-office operations to reduce risk and losses due to human error or theft, and verifies procedural compliance at every location. Kruger will explain how you can acquire banking relationships, prepare for taxes and audits with data exports, and maintain compliance with state regulations through automation.

Click here to watch the recording

Five Ingredients for a Successful Cannabis License Application

By Sara Gullickson
No Comments

In the rapidly evolving cannabis industry, in both new and emerging markets, securing a cannabis license is an essential step to establishing a successful business. However, navigating the application process can be complex, challenging and highly competitive.

To help aspiring entrepreneurs and investors in this burgeoning field, The Cannabis Business Advisors founder and CEO, Sara Gullickson, shares her top five ingredients for a successful cannabis license application. According to Gullickson, who has secured more than 75 licenses in over 30 states and five countries, these ingredients, when combined strategically, can significantly increase your chances of obtaining a coveted license and positioning your cannabis business for long-term success. 

1. Real Estate

The author, Sara Gullickson (left) with Maxime Kot (right), president of The Cannabis Business Advisors

Real estate is the foundation of success. One of the key elements in a successful cannabis license application is securing suitable real estate. Many markets require applicants to have a designated location or property before even applying for a license. Finding the right property that complies with local zoning regulations and satisfies the specific requirements of cannabis operations is crucial. Partnering with experienced real estate professionals who understand the intricacies of the industry can be invaluable. By securing a well-suited location, you demonstrate to regulators your commitment to compliance and responsible business practices.

2. Finance

The cannabis industry brings its own set of unique challenges to navigate. The federal illegality of cannabis creates significant obstacles when accessing traditional banking and loans. Therefore, having a smart financial advisor and a comprehensive financial plan is essential for a successful license application. A well-prepared financial strategy, including accurate budgeting, projections and contingency plans, showcases your ability to manage financial resources effectively. It also demonstrates to regulators and investors that you have a sustainable and profitable business model, even amid industry uncertainties.

3. Community Support

Building strong relationships with the local community is crucial for a successful cannabis license application. Engaging with community leaders, neighborhood organizations and residents is a way to demonstrate your commitment to being a responsible and contributing member of the community. Actively seeking input, addressing concerns and incorporating feedback can help alleviate potential opposition and increase your chances of receiving support from local authorities during the licensing process. Community support is a powerful asset that showcases your dedication to fostering positive change and creating economic opportunities within the region.

4. Industry Experience

Value the expertise of the pioneers. While the cannabis industry is still nascent, there are seasoned industry pros who have been navigating its intricacies for over a decade. Leveraging their expertise and industry knowledge can be instrumental in crafting a successful application. Collaborating with experienced consultants and advisors who understand the unique challenges and nuances of the cannabis industry can provide invaluable guidance throughout the licensing process. Their insights into compliance, operational best practices and regulatory requirements can help you develop a robust application that stands out among competitors.

5. Team

The composition of your team is the cornerstone of your success and plays a vital role in the success of your cannabis license application. Assembling a knowledgeable and diverse team with expertise in various aspects of the industry is essential. From cultivation and manufacturing to retail and compliance, each team member should bring specialized skills and experience that align with your business objectives. Demonstrating a well-rounded team with a track record of success increases your credibility and instills confidence in regulators and investors alike. Your team represents your brand and serves as the backbone of your operations, making it crucial to prioritize hiring and cultivating talent.

Securing a cannabis license is critical to establishing a successful business in the rapidly growing cannabis industry. By focusing on real estate, finance, community support, industry experience and a strong team—you can significantly enhance your chances of success in the licensing process. Partnering with experienced consultants, leveraging the knowledge of industry veterans and demonstrating a commitment to compliance and responsible business practices will position you for long-term success in this dynamic and evolving industry.

California’s Social Equity Fee Waiver – Late Is Better Than Never

By Abraham Finberg, Rachel Wright, Simon Menkes
No Comments

In a move that Old Guard California Cannabis viewed with bittersweet appreciation, the Department of Cannabis Control on January 1, 2022 announced it would waive license fees for those cannabis companies impacted by the War on Cannabis. Many pre-2017 operators experienced persecution by law enforcement including confiscation of inventory. For those who refused to admit defeat and remained in or returned to the business of cannabis, this significant fee waiver feels something like an apology.

As we move through Year 2 of the Equity Fee Waiver, it’s important for all cannabis companies to review their history and their current operations to see if they qualify for this significant reduction in expense. Instead of arrest or conviction, a cannabis business may also qualify through its eligible owner’s income level or location of residence. Since this is a fee waiver for small businesses, a maximum yearly revenue level of $5 million is also a requirement.

For those Qualified Equity Licensees who have already received a fee waiver, it’s important to remember that this is a yearly process, and that they must continue to submit a request for equity fee relief at least 60 calendar days before the annual expiration date of their license.

Who Qualifies for the Equity Fee Waiver?

Gross Revenue: Your cannabis business must have no more than $5 Million gross revenue per year.

Equity Ownership: At least 50% of your business must be owned by people who have only ONE of these three characteristics:

  • Have experienced a cannabis conviction or arrest, or
  • Have a lower income level, or
  • Reside in a neighborhood affected by the criminalization of cannabis (as defined by the DCC)

Arrest or Conviction

The DCC requires that the equity individual have been convicted or arrested for cannabis crimes before November 8, 2016. Crimes must have been sale, possession, use, manufacture or cultivation. The equity individual may also be eligible if an immediate family member was convicted or arrested for cannabis crimes and the equity individual themselves lived in a California county with drug arrest rates that were higher than the state average drug arrest rates.

Lower Income Level

In order to qualify under income level, the equity individual must have household income no more than 60% of the area’s median income (see DCC charts showing county, number of people in household, and eligible income levels) or prove eligibility for financial aid like CalFresh or Medi-Cal or Supplemental Security Income.

Residence in a Neighborhood Affected by Criminalization of Cannabis

If an equity individual seeks to qualify by location of residence, they must have lived in the qualified location for at least 5 years between 1980 and 2016. The location must have higher than state average drug arrests and be in the top 25% nationally for unemployment and poverty. The DCC provides an interactive map to check your location for these requirements.

Worth the Trouble

Again, your business needs to be below $5 million annual gross revenue, and at least 50% of the ownership needs to have only 1 of 3 disadvantaged characteristics: cannabis arrest or conviction, or lower income level, or residence in an affected neighborhood.

While it will definitely take time to apply for the Equity Fee Waiver, the savings in zeroed-out license fees can certainly make it worthwhile. In addition, qualifying for the Equity Fee Waiver makes a business eligible for other state equity tax advantages including the California Equity Tax Credit. (See our article on the CETC here.)

The state’s application for the Equity Fee Waiver is available online, and more info is available as well.

The Distressed Cannabis Business: An Alternative to Bankruptcy

By Paula Durham, Scott E. Evans
No Comments

Bankruptcy is Not an Option

Bankruptcy courts do not provide protection to cannabis and cannabis-related businesses.Bankruptcy can be a very helpful tool for a distressed business. Bankruptcy allows a business to stop collection actions, discharge certain debts, cancel unfavorable contracts and provides breathing room to restructure the business.

What if your cannabis operation is struggling or failing – file for bankruptcy, right? Not so fast. Despite cannabis being legalized or decriminalized for certain activities at the state level, it remains illegal at the federal level. Therefore, the bankruptcy court will not provide protection to cannabis and cannabis-related businesses (CRB).

Alternatives to Bankruptcy

A State Court receiver may be the best alternative when bankruptcy is not an option.Enter the state court receivership. Receivership is an equitable remedy that is often employed as an alternative to a bankruptcy proceeding. A receivership can address business insolvency or can be a temporary remedy during legal proceedings between disputing business partners, with control of the enterprise hanging in the balance.

In either scenario, the court appointed receiver takes control of the business and must assess the posture of the business and determine the best path forward. The receiver’s options run the gamut from operating the company as is, restructuring operations to maximize profit or closing shop and liquidating the business as a whole or in pieces. The receiver has a fiduciary responsibility to determine the option that best satisfies creditors, similar to duties required of a trustee in a bankruptcy.

The importance of having a receiver well-versed in the cannabis industry cannot be overstated.Distressed cannabis companies are often prime candidates for receivership. Cannabis is a burgeoning industry with huge growth and profit potential. However, worlds have collided in the Green Rush, where business-minded individuals, often with little knowledge of cannabis, have partnered with individuals well-versed in cannabis culture, cultivation and consumption, but with little experience operating a business. Add a dash of complex state laws and regulatory drama in the form of the federal/state divide on legality, a dollop of fraud potential due to the largely all-cash nature of the business and you’ve created the perfect recipe for insolvency, litigation or both. In these often-chaotic conditions it is easy for a cannabis company to become unprofitable. A receiver can add significant value by stabilizing the business while the litigation proceeds or while developing a restructuring plan. In either case the goal of a receivership is to maximize the value of a business for the benefit of its stakeholders.

If you are considering restructuring options for your cannabis operation, a receivership can be an excellent choice. However, a cannabis receivership is not for the faint of heart. There are two significant areas that distinguish cannabis receiverships from receiverships involving non-cannabis businesses: First, the complex regulatory environment and second, banking. The importance of having a receiver well-versed in the cannabis industry cannot be overstated. Making a mistake in these areas can cause more harm than good. 

Complex Regulatory Environment

Cannabis operations are subject to a complicated regulatory framework that varies by state as well as by type of legalization (medical versus adult use cannabis). Receivers unfamiliar with the cannabis industry and the associated regulatory framework will be behind the curve on day one.

Upon appointment over a cannabis entity a receiver becomes responsible for the regulatory posture of that entity.Regulatory hurdles begin at the outset of a receivership. Although receivership is an excellent restructuring option for cannabis operators in distress, regulations surrounding the authorization requirements for those operating the business on a day-to-day basis (including receivers) vary by state. Some states, but not all, even have specific regulations for receiverships.

For example, the rules and regulations for cannabis operators in Colorado administered by the Colorado Marijuana Enforcement Division (MED) include provisions for receiverships. Specifically, the MED requires court appointees, including receivers, to register with the State Licensing Authority as Temporary Appointee[s] of the Court within seven days of appointment.

Similarly, Washington State cannabis regulations directly address receiverships. Specifically, Title 314 allows receivers or trustees to operate a licensed cannabis business, but the receiver must be qualified by the Washington State Liquor Control Board (LCB). Qualification requirements include  active status on the LCB preapproved receiver list or submission of an application to serve as a receiver for a licensee within two days of appointment. Furthermore, to serve as a receiver of a Washington state cannabis licensee the receiver must meet residency requirements.

Conversely, the Arizona cannabis laws and rules do not specifically address cannabis receiverships. Nevertheless, Arizona does require anyone volunteering or working at a medical or recreational cannabis dispensary to be registered with the Arizona Department of Health Services as either a Dispensary Agent (DA) or a Facility Agent (FA). Therefore, a receiver appointed over a licensed cannabis business in Arizona must obtain the applicable registration upon appointment in order to take control of the licensed entity in a compliant manner.

The fun doesn’t stop after the initial appointment hurdles are cleared. The regulatory environment across the country is a patchwork of complex laws. States that have legalized or decriminalized cannabis on some level have instituted often complex rules surrounding the cultivation, manufacture, wholesale and retail sale of cannabis. Even seemingly simple concepts such as the definition of cannabis are not so simple in some states. For example, Massachusetts includes cannabidiol (CBD) in its definition of cannabis while Arizona does not.

Some states, like California, do not allow the sale of cannabis licenses. Other states, like Colorado, allow for the transfer of commercial cannabis licenses. In a turnaround situation it is particularly important to understand the options available to liquidate a licensee’s assets.

Similarly, many, but not all states have rules requiring cannabis product testing by accredited laboratories prior to retail sale. Most states require THC potency testing, while others (like California and Colorado) also require testing for pesticides and toxins. Conversely, testing for toxins and contaminates is voluntary in Florida. Product testing is expensive and time-consuming, and operators must have a comprehensive system in place to ensure compliant product is available for sale to retail and wholesale customers.

Even taxes are different for cannabis businesses. A receiver must understand and be able to manage a cannabis business in order to comply with and minimize taxes under the infamous 280e regulations of the U.S. tax code.

Upon appointment over a cannabis entity a receiver becomes responsible for the regulatory posture of that entity. Accordingly, the receiver must ensure that any regulatory deficiencies are identified and corrected in order to ensure compliant operation.

We’ve highlighted just a few of the myriad of regulatory concerns facing a receiver upon appointment. It is critical to engage a receiver who has experience working under the complex cannabis regulatory structure for your distressed cannabis operation.

Banking

One of the most important things a receiver does upon appointment is to identify and secure the assets of the entity in receivership, including cash. This normally involves opening a bank account in the name of the receivership entity that is controlled solely by the receiver and moving cash assets into the controlled account.

This typically ordinary task is not so easy with a cannabis operation. Because cannabis remains illegal under federal law, processing funds derived from the sale of cannabis (even sales that are legal at the state level) can be considered by the Department of Justice (DOJ) as aiding and abetting criminal activity or money laundering.A receiver must negotiate the complex banking regulations regarding cannabis businesses and effectively manage the large amounts of cash, which may not be bankable.

The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCen) issued guidance in 2014 that cleared the way for financial institutions to service canna-businesses (2014 Guidance). The 2014 Guidance requires financial institutions who choose to provide services to CRBs to design and implement a thorough customer due diligence review that includes, in part, analyzing the licensing of the entity, developing an understanding of the business operations of the entity, and ongoing monitoring of the entity. In addition, financial institutions are required to file a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) for every transaction they process for a CRB, should they choose to accept the business.

While this is a positive step forward, it is a heavy compliance burden that comes at a cost. Naturally, compliance costs incurred by banks to service cannabis operators are passed on to the customer; fees of $2,500 per month per account are not uncommon. The high compliance costs, coupled with the significant regulatory risk, keeps most banks out of the cannabis market; thus, making it hard, but not impossible, for a receiver appointed over a cannabis operation or CRB to obtain banking.

While banking options do exist, the reality is that most canna-businesses operate on a cash basis. Distressed cannabis operations may not have the cashflow to afford banking services, at least at the outset of a receivership. Further compounding the banking problem, some banks that are open to cannabis are not open to receiverships, further limiting banking options.

A receiver therefore must be prepared to quickly secure all cash assets of the receivership entity and ensure appropriate internal controls are in place to control cash on an ongoing basis.

Cannabis has been legalized or decriminalized in a majority of U.S. states but remains illegal at the federal level. Therefore, federal bankruptcy protection is not generally an option available for a distressed canna business. However, not all is lost because state receiverships offer an excellent restructuring option for distressed cannabis operations.

Minnesota Legalizes Adult Use Cannabis: Part 2

By Abraham Finberg, Rachel Wright, Simon Menkes
No Comments

In Part 1, we examined the current status of adult use cannabis in Minnesota, paying particular attention to the licensing framework, taxation and social equity considerations. In this article, we’ll cover some important need-to-know info if you’re considering opening an adult use business in the “Land of 10,000 Lakes.”

Starting a Cannabis Business in Minnesota: Important Considerations

As the state does not expect to begin issuing licenses before the first quarter of 2025, now is the time to plan a licensing campaign. With a population of 5,714,000, 64% of which live in the Twin Cities of Minneapolis-Saint Paul, Minnesota is close in population to Colorado, with 5,774,000 residents. Colorado currently has around $1.8 billion in yearly retail cannabis sales. This may suggest a similar possible level of sales for Minnesota once its retail cannabis market matures.

In a recent op-ed piece for Marijuana Moment, the New York cannabis consulting firm of Bridge West Consulting suggested three reasons, in addition to low cannabis excise taxes and reasonable license fees, why entrepreneurs should consider investing in a retail cannabis business in Minnesota:

  • Minnesota legislation prohibits localities from banning cannabis businesses. This avoids serious problems that have plagued cannabis businesses in other states including California and Montana in which access for cannabis companies has been denied and, in Montana’s case, even reversed. (Minnesota’s new legislation does allow local governments to limit the number of cannabis retailers to one for every 12,500 residents, however.)
  • Minnesota has allocated funds to assist social equity cannabis businesses, including $6 million to the CanStartup which will fund non-profits to make loans to budding cannabis businesses.
  • Bridge West makes the interesting observation that Minnesota is bordered by four states—Wisconsin, Iowa, South Dakota and North Dakota—none of which have legalized adult use cannabis. Moreover, an estimated 1.9 million people live outside of Minnesota within a 50-mile radius. That means that not only will Minnesotans not have to compete with out-of-state cannabis dispensaries but will benefit from the purchases of out-of-state residents that live within a comfortable distance.

How a License Application is Scored

HF100 gives some guidance as to how the Office of Cannabis Management (OCM) will score license applications, awarding points for the following 9 categories: social equity status, veteran status, security and record keeping, employee training plan, business plan and financial situation, diversity plan, labor and employment practices, knowledge and experience and environmental plan.

The OCM may award additional points if the applicant would expand service to an underrepresented market. Points may also be awarded to those applicants who can demonstrate a negative impact from cannabis prohibition such as arrest or imprisonment of the applicant or their immediate family. This is different from social equity status and the law says points may be awarded to the applicants “in the same manner as points are awarded to social equity applicants.”

Emphasis on Market Stability; Prohibition of Vertical Integration

Minnesota is taking measures to ensure “market stability,” which it doesn’t specifically define, but which it says involves:

  1. Ensuring an adequate supply of cannabis, but not a glut.
  2. Eliminating the illicit cannabis market.
  3. Promoting a craft cannabis industry.
  4. Prioritizing growth and recovery in communities that have experienced a disproportionate, negative impact from cannabis prohibition.

HF100 states, “The office shall issue the necessary number of licenses in order to ensure the sufficient supply of cannabis flower and cannabinoid products to meet demand, provide market stability, and limit the sale of unregulated cannabis flower and cannabinoid products.”

Continuing its emphasis on “smaller is better,” HF100 says, “Unless the office determines that the issuance of bulk cultivator licenses is necessary to ensure a sufficient supply of cannabis flower and cannabinoid products, the office shall not issue a bulk cultivator license before July 1, 2028.”

Vertical integration is also prohibited. “The office shall not issue licenses to a single applicant that would result in the applicant being vertically integrated.” HF100 goes on to state that microbusinesses are exempted, and that if the OCM determines that vertical integration is necessary to ensure a sufficient supply of cannabis and cannabis products during the first year of such products being sold to customers, it may authorize one or more applicants to be vertically integrated. However, such a group of licenses are very temporary and will expire at the end of that first year period.

An entity holding a cannabis retailer license may also hold a delivery license, a medical retailer license and an event organizer license. But no retailer may hold any other license. Also, no entity may own or operate more than one retail business in one city or county.

Interestingly, Minnesota is also allowing cities or counties to own and operate a municipal cannabis store, possibly similar to the way Utah has government liquor stores which compete with private bars, breweries, wineries and distilleries.

In Summary

Minnesota is just beginning to define and establish its adult use cannabis market. Like other states before it, it is attempting to promote social equity aims at the same time as it’s working to avoid the serious problems of a competitive illegal market and an over-or-under supply of cannabis to its citizens.

With low license fees and excise taxes and a good-sized population, 420CPA believes cannabis entrepreneurs should seriously consider Minnesota for possible investment. The first cannabis retail businesses are not expected to open for another 18 months, so now is the time for businesspeople to lay the groundwork for their applications and future locations.

The Sensory Branding Opportunity for Cannabis Products

By Dr. Ed Szczygiel
1 Comment

Cannabis brands are facing a proverbial fork in the road: determining whether their product evolves into a luxury consumable or affordable agricultural commodity. While it is reasonable to assume the cannabis market space will organically grow into a luxury goods industry such as wine and spirits, the luxury brands that serve as the foundation of these markets were built over years of engagement between consumers, connoisseurs and producers. If cannabis companies want to successfully market their products as luxury items, a concerted effort towards well-defined, consumer-accessible branding is required.

The first step towards evolving a cannabis brand towards luxury is overcoming the fixation on cultivar identity. Unregulated cultivar naming currently impedes creativity and craftsmanship, disrupting brands and salespersons’ abilities to clearly communicate strain aesthetics.

The good news is the alcohol, coffee and consumer packaged food (CPG) industries have done most of the heavy lifting, paving the way with robust sensory science and analytical approaches to product characterization. Cannabis stakeholders need only adapt their tools and apply them to cannabis with similar intention.

Research suggests that aroma is one of the strongest predictors of positive consumption experience. As adult use consumers become familiar with current product offerings and increasingly legal availability, they will seek products that consistently yield the best experience. The most successful brands will be those that most effectively communicate that experience and then deliver it. The status quo – describing aroma using strain names, top terpenes or THC content – is not effective at harmonizing a brand’s promise with consumer experience.

Figure 1: Illustration of both the conventional branding approach (top) and the sensory-based branding opportunity (bottom).

The conventional cannabis product branding approach leaves to be desired a tremendous opportunity to characterize cultivars (Figure 1). Sensory science, the discipline used to evoke, measure, analyze and interpret reactions to materials through human perception, has been used for decades to characterize CPGs from skin lotion to washing machines. Adapting these well-established techniques for use in cannabis can be challenging, but it is certainly worth the investment.

These shifts in the cannabis industry have already begun to occur. I recently was the principle investigator on a white paper that presented a novel cannabis aroma wheel derived from aroma descriptors and a panel of trained sensory experts. In the study, sensory scientists evaluated randomly sampled cannabis flower over a period of several months. The researchers combined qualitative focus panels, literature review and formal blinded sensory tests to develop a comprehensive lexicon that served as a tool for trained evaluators to characterize cannabis aroma. This novel and robust tool (Figure 2) was designed to be used by trained panels to characterize cannabis aroma, is freely available and is just the beginning of a collective development of a data-driven cannabis lexicon.

Much like the World Coffee Research Lexicon referenced here, the Cannabis Aroma Lexicon is a tool with a specific purpose: collecting an objective description of the product aroma. It is a living document that will grow along with the industry. In the future, we may have lexicons to describe more than just aroma. Tactile and appearance sensory attributes of cannabis will gradually be defined by sensory scientists, presenting more opportunities for deep craftsmanship in the cannabis industry.

Figure 2: Expert-derived aroma wheel tool for cannabis aroma characterization.

The role that dispensaries play in adoption of standardized quality metrics is critical. The product features that position cannabis to be a craft product warrant the presence of a third-party expert to translate and guide consumers during the purchasing process. It’s intuitive to ask a waiter to recommend a pairing (i.e., a dry red wine to pair with a seafood dish), given the trust that consumers put in the restaurant to understand the properties of the food they are serving. Dispensaries have thus far filled the service structure role for cannabis, but the vast amount of unknowns regarding the physiological and sensorial effects of cannabis have resulted in inconsistent experiences that leave something to be desired in terms of consumer trust.

Application of sensory science in cannabis is an unparalleled opportunity for brands to build consumer trust and differentiate their products in a sea of strain names and high potency flower. Cultivars that can be established as measurably aromatic in a specific character can leverage that aroma profile to add significant value to the product. For example:

  • Cultivar name can be aligned with the perceived aroma (e.g., garlic is not bad, but expecting tropical and getting garlic can harm consumer trust).
  • Product catalog can be consolidated and optimized to avoid sales cannibalization by growing specific products to meet consumer group’s needs.
  • Guesswork is removed from breeding by measuring when a product is meeting sensory goals and ensuring it doesn’t drift over time.
  • Demonstrating transparency will win over ethical consumers. Utilizing controlled, blinded studies to profile aromas will add value to ethics-minded consumers.
  • Becoming a leader in connoisseurship. In the forefront of this shift in branding, one can position a brand to be ahead of the competition.
  • Elevating the dispensary experience. By utilizing aroma profiling, products can be more easily sold by budtenders and salespeople.
  • Opening doors to new application types (e.g., seasonal, occasion centered or geographically unique cultivars).

These are just some of the ways that aroma characterization will differentiate products and simultaneously contribute to cannabis brands’ ability to communicate craftsmanship and the maturity of the industry as whole. Not only will adoption of robust sensory-based branding improve the consumer experience by providing a means to compare products to one another, it will promote adoption of good manufacturing practices that simultaneously improve the quality and safety of cannabis products. Without consumer-accessible quality metrics, brands have little incentive to produce products of elevated quality and are conversely incentivized to prioritize quantity and meet minimum regulatory requirements.

Importantly, cannabis businesses will use this tool to adapt to an inevitable industry-wide shift towards connoisseurship and application of robust sensory science. While it may be challenging to shake off the “bad habits” that currently plague many brands, cannabis has significant potential as a luxury good. Consumers are eager for a better cannabis experience from purchase to consumption. How will your brand use sensory profiling to expand or evolve product offerings to succeed in a cannabis market full of luxury brands and what steps will you take now to prepare?